After the premiere of “Milkmaids,” fans took to Reddit to discuss their feelings. Redditor u/inthearchipelago posted a discussion about the episode, explaining,, “Of any episode of American Horror Story, American Horror Stories, any Ryan Murphy production (including the entirety of Glee), any episode of American television, any episode of horror television, in every single way, from the acting to the editing to the camera work to the music, not one moment was redeemable, I wish not only that it had been even further delayed, but that Hulu had never dropped it, 0/10.”
Apparently, there were no redeeming qualities about this episode according to the discussion’s creator. Not only did they criticize the acting, but they also called out the production quality as a whole. Claiming that the entire episode was irredeemable felt a bit extreme, but their visceral reaction to “Milkmaids” got a conversation about the episode buzzing quickly.
Many fans agreed that the episode was horrible. U/atclubsilencio said, “This is how I felt. Really solid, if disgusting, first half, was expecting it go in a different direction, gave me ‘Roanoke’ vibes, and then completely nosedived.”
“Roanoke,” of course, refers to Season 6 of “American Horror Story,” which might be one of the worst-received seasons of the series ever created. While the season started out strong by mimicking a docu-horror style TV show, when they returned to Roanoke, the entire plot plummeted into the ground.
ncG1vNJzZmhqZGy7psPSmqmorZ6Zwamx1qippZxemLyue9OrnKecmaO0cK3Mnqmim5Gjeqm70aumq2WjqbyztcSsZJ%2BZnqh6orPRnpxmpZmhuK6tyJ2qZqicpMFuw8CsZK6mkpq5qrHVmpmlnV8%3D